Photo: Star / Unsplash
If there’s one thing more unpredictable than the housing market itself, it’s the experts who try to predict it. These financial forecasters often speak with the confidence of someone who’s never been wrong—right up until the moment they are. To prove this point, here are five spectacular housing market predictions that aged about as well as a 1970s shag carpet.
1. The “Millennials Will Never Buy Houses” Theory (2008-2015)
Remember when every economist and their dog insisted millennials would forever be renters? The theory went that this generation, supposedly more interested in avocado toast than assets, would revolutionize housing by rejecting homeownership entirely.
Fast-forward to 2024, and millennials make up the largest segment of homebuyers. In Australia, millennials most commonly find a local builder in Ocean Grove, Geelong, and other small towns in the outer reaches of Melbourne. In the US, the Mountain West and Sun Belt regions are booming. Best of all, many millennials are buying and building houses while still enjoying their fancy breakfasts.
2. The “2021 Housing Bubble Pop” Prophecy
Early 2021 saw countless experts predicting an imminent housing market collapse that would make 2008 look like a minor hiccup. Instead, house prices continued their skyward journey, defying gravity and logic in equal measure. Some markets saw increases that made Bitcoin’s volatility look positively stable. The bubble didn’t pop—it just kept expanding. Does that mean we just kicked “the pop” down the road? Only time will tell.
3. The “Remote Work Will Kill City Housing” Forecast
When remote work became widespread in 2020, experts rushed to declare the death of urban housing markets. According to these predictions, cities would become ghost towns as workers fled to rural paradises. While some urban markets did see temporary dips, most rebounded faster than you can say “hybrid work schedule.” Turns out, people still enjoy being within walking distance of overpriced coffee shops and cultural attractions.
4. The “Interest Rates Will Stay Low Forever” Guarantee
Throughout the 2010s, numerous housing experts confidently declared that interest rates would remain at historic lows “indefinitely.” Some even suggested negative rates might become the norm. These predictions proved about as reliable as a cardboard bathing suit. When rates started climbing, many of these same experts suddenly became very interested in discussing other topics.
5. The “Gen Z Will Only Live in Tiny Houses” Idea
Despite the failure of the Millennial Predictions Playbook, experts began forecasting that Gen Z would reject traditional housing in favor of micro-homes and converted shipping containers. Early data suggests Gen Z actually has surprisingly conventional housing preferences—they just want homes they can afford, ideally with enough space to store their vintage clothing collections.
The Art of Getting It Wrong
What these failed predictions teach us goes beyond real estate. They reveal our collective tendency to extrapolate current trends indefinitely into the future, while underestimating humanity’s capacity for adaptation and change.
The housing market remains as complex as ever, influenced by everything from global economics to local zoning laws and whether people think their neighbor’s new garden gnome collection is charming or horrifying. Perhaps the most accurate prediction would be that predictions themselves will continue to be unreliable.
So, the next time you hear an expert making bold claims about the future of housing, remember these monumental misses. If you’re looking to buy or sell in the current market, the best approach might be to focus less on predictions and more on your personal circumstances. After all, a home’s true value isn’t just in its potential appreciation—it’s in having a place where you can paint the walls whatever color you want, even if it makes guests question your judgment.
